YouTube Shorts by Niche | Insights, InFocus Media Group

A study of 18,000 YouTube channels found Shorts help some niches and hurt others.

Fitness, food, business and education channels gain from mixing in Shorts. Gaming, science, beauty and entertainment lose from it. Travel and home and DIY sit in between, where the format barely makes a difference either way.

InFocus Media Group · 3 min read

Written by Shawn Peach. Every figure traced to its source before publication.

AIR Media-Tech tracked 18,000 English-language YouTube channels from March 2025 to March 2026, split between channels running long-form only and channels mixing in Shorts. There is no universal answer to whether Shorts help a channel grow. Fitness, food, business and education channels running a modest Shorts ratio, roughly 25 to 40 per cent of uploads, showed up to 41 per cent more subscribers than long-form-only channels in the same niche. Gaming, science, beauty and entertainment channels showed the opposite. Long-form-only channels held as much as 85 to 90 per cent more subscribers at scale than channels mixing formats.

Why this matters now

Most of what gets said about Shorts is one creator’s experience. One adds Shorts, watches the long-form views climb, credits the format and posts about it. Another adds Shorts, watches the opposite happen and posts the reverse. Both are telling the truth about their own channel, and neither tells you much about yours, because one channel says nothing reliable about a different niche or a different audience.

What has been missing is scale, a sample wide enough that the outliers cancel out and the actual pattern is what is left.

41%

The gain only shows up when a channel's niche is fitness, food, business or education. In gaming, the same move can cost a channel close to half its subscribers against a long-form-only rival the same size.

Source: AIR Media-Tech, Do YouTube Shorts help your long-form videos? Data from 18,000 channels

Where the split falls

Niche decides it more than effort or execution alone. Fitness channels adding Shorts saw the strongest lift in the study, food and cooking close behind, and business and education channels benefited at a similar rate once Shorts sat in that 25 to 40 per cent band of total uploads. Push past 55 per cent and the pattern reverses even in a niche where mixing helps, Shorts start crowding out the long-form content the audience actually subscribed for. Gaming showed the widest gap in the whole dataset, with long-form-only channels carrying close to double the subscribers of channels mixing in Shorts at the same size. Two niches sat almost dead centre: travel, and home and DIY. For those, format mix moved next to nothing.

What this means for your channel

Travel and home and DIY are two of the categories this data says don’t move on format mix. Under one per cent of a subscriber difference either way isn’t worth spending production time on. What does move those channels is what it always was: a search-led title that says what the video is and who it’s for, with the description and the chapters backing it up.

A golf or leisure club channel sits closer to education and lifestyle than to gaming or beauty, so closer to the niches where the gain shows up. We would test a modest Shorts ratio there rather than assume either way.

Don’t pick your format on one viral video or one bad quarter. The channels that get this right test their own mix against their own niche’s numbers instead of copying whoever posted about it last.

Sources AIR Media-Tech, Do YouTube Shorts help your long-form videos? Data from 18,000 channels

Before you spend on Shorts, let us have a look at your niche’s numbers.

Tell us what you're working on ← Back to Insights How we do YouTube optimisation → Next: Australian video ad spend →